Alternatives To CPAP: Options For Sleep Apnea Without A Mask

Quick Answer: The main alternatives to CPAP are oral appliances, side sleeping, lifestyle changes, nerve stimulation, surgery and mouth exercises. NHLBI says a provider may prescribe an oral device if you cannot use CPAP. A sleep medicine guideline says CPAP should still generally be the first-line option, so choose any alternative with a doctor and follow-up testing.

Struggling with the mask? Try how to get used to CPAP first.

Why Look For Alternatives To CPAP?

NHLBI says a PAP machine is the most common treatment for sleep apnea, but it is not easy for everyone. Side effects may include congestion, dry eyes or mouth, nosebleeds or a runny nose (NHLBI). Some people do not want to wear a mask at all.

If that is you, tell your provider before you stop. Ask about other options, or about fixing the problem with the machine. For the full list of treatments, see sleep apnea treatment. This guide is for education only and is not medical advice.

Try A Different PAP Type Before Giving Up

CPAP is only one kind of PAP machine. NHLBI lists three, and says to talk to your provider about which type is most appropriate for you:

  • CPAP gives constant air pressure through your mouth, nose or both.
  • BPAP is like CPAP but delivers different pressure when you inhale and when you exhale.
  • APAP adjusts the air pressure automatically during sleep.

NHLBI also says to stop using your PAP machine and contact your provider if you get stomach discomfort or bloating. A different machine type, mask or setting may solve the problem, so raise it at your next visit.

Sleep Apnea Treatment Without CPAP At A Glance

Option Who It May Suit Main Limit
Oral appliance Adults who cannot tolerate CPAP or prefer another option (AASM guideline) CPAP lowers breathing events more; needs a dentist and follow-up
Side sleeping People whose provider recommends it (NHLBI) The sources here give no numbers on how much it helps
Lifestyle changes Anyone with sleep apnea, alongside other care (NHLBI) Needs steady effort; may not be enough alone
Nerve stimulation Surgical option listed by NHLBI Needs an implant under the skin of the chest
Surgery Selected cases, such as tonsil removal or jaw advancement (NHLBI) Surgical risks; suitability depends on the cause
Mouth and tongue exercises Adults, alone or with other care (meta-analysis) Few trials, and results varied between them

Oral Appliances: Do Mouth Guards For Sleep Apnea Work?

An oral appliance is a mouthpiece placed in the mouth to prevent blocked airways during sleep. NHLBI describes two types. Mandibular repositioning mouthpieces cover the upper and lower teeth and hold the lower jaw in place. Tongue-retaining devices hold the tongue forward. A dentist or orthodontist custom fits them.

A sleep medicine guideline recommends that sleep physicians consider an oral appliance, rather than no treatment, for adults with obstructive sleep apnea who are intolerant of CPAP or prefer another option (AASM and AADSM guideline).

It also suggests a qualified dentist provide follow-up to check for dental side effects, and that doctors repeat sleep testing to confirm the device works. The review behind it found two separate things, shown below.

The review also says the quality-of-life gain from custom, adjustable oral appliances was not inferior to CPAP. It rates that evidence as moderate, and the evidence comparing the two directly as low.

Oral Appliance Results From the AASM Review Two separate results from the review. Compared with no device, oral appliances lowered breathing events by a mean of 13.6 an hour, in 34 trials with 1,301 patients. Compared with oral appliances, CPAP lowered them by a mean of 6.24 an hour more, in studies with 491 oral appliance and 481 CPAP patients. Two Separate Results 13.6fewer events an hourwith an oral appliancethan with no device 6.24more events an hourremoved by CPAP thanby an oral appliance Source: AASM and AADSM review. Mean differences.

So an oral appliance helps compared with no device, but CPAP lowered breathing events more.

In one study in the review, 73.2 percent of CPAP users and 42.8 percent of oral appliance users had a complete response, meaning at least a 50 percent drop to under 5 events an hour. These figures come from different comparisons, so do not treat them as a ranking. See how to read sleep study results if you have a report to check.

Positional Therapy For Sleep Apnea

NHLBI says your provider may recommend that you sleep on your side, not on your back, because this can help keep your airway open while you sleep.

The sources we used give no figures on how much it helps. Ask your doctor whether your apnea is worse on your back, and have it tested. NHLBI places side sleeping alongside its lifestyle advice, so it may be one part of a plan, not a stand-alone fix.

Weight Loss And Lifestyle Changes

NHLBI says healthy lifestyle changes can be very effective for treating sleep apnea. It also says PAP machines often work best when paired with them. The changes it lists are:

  • Regular physical activity.
  • Healthy sleeping habits.
  • A healthy weight.
  • Limiting alcohol and caffeine.
  • Quitting smoking.

The link with weight is explained in sleep apnea and weight gain. Alcohol and smoking are on the same NHLBI list.

Hypoglossal Nerve Stimulation

This is a surgical option. NHLBI says a device is implanted under the skin of the chest and connects to the nerve under your tongue to keep your airways open. The page gives no rules on who qualifies, so ask a sleep specialist. See when to see a sleep specialist.

Surgery For Sleep Apnea

NHLBI lists these surgical options, in addition to nerve stimulation:

  • Tonsillectomy, to remove your tonsils.
  • Surgery to remove tissue from the mouth and throat to make the upper airway larger.
  • Upper or lower jaw advancement, to move the jaws forward.
  • Weight-loss surgery, if obesity contributes to your sleep apnea and other treatments do not work.

The right choice depends on what is narrowing your airway, so a specialist should guide it.

Mouth And Tongue Exercises

NHLBI says exercises for the mouth and facial muscles, called orofacial therapy, may be an effective treatment in children and adults. They aim to strengthen and reposition the tongue and the muscles of the lips, upper airway and face. NHLBI also lists removable tongue muscle stimulators, mouthpieces used once a day while awake that stimulate and tone the tongue.

A meta-analysis of four trials found that exercises alone lowered the apnea-hypopnea index (AHI) by a mean of 8.85 events an hour before and after therapy, and results were consistent across the trials. Compared with a control group, the drop was 5.29 events an hour, but results varied a lot between trials (meta-analysis). Adding exercises to CPAP made no significant difference compared with CPAP alone.

Mouth Exercise Results From One Meta-Analysis Three separate results from a meta-analysis of four trials. Exercises alone, before and after: AHI fell by a mean of 8.85 events an hour. Exercises versus a control group: 5.29 fewer events an hour, with large differences between trials. Exercises plus CPAP versus CPAP alone: no significant difference. Exercises: Three Results 8.85fewer events an hourbefore and afterexercises alone 5.29fewer events an hourvs a control group(results varied) Nonesignificant differencewhen added to CPAPvs CPAP alone Source: orofacial therapy meta-analysis. Mean differences.

The three cards come from the same four trials but answer different questions. The review’s high variation means these exercises are promising, not proven, so treat them as a support to care from your doctor.

How To Check An Alternative Is Working

Any option should be confirmed with testing. A good plan looks like this:

  1. Get a sleep study first, so you know your starting severity (home sleep apnea test is one route).
  2. Agree a treatment with your doctor and a dentist if it is an oral appliance.
  3. Keep follow-up visits. The guideline suggests dentist oversight for oral appliances.
  4. Repeat sleep testing to confirm the treatment works, as the guideline suggests.
  5. Note your daytime sleepiness and your partner’s report of snoring or pauses.

Compare your new test with the first one. Your AHI should fall, and you should feel less sleepy. If neither changes, go back to your doctor.

Should You Stop Using CPAP?

Do not stop CPAP on your own. The AASM review concluded that CPAP should still generally be the first-line option. Talk to your doctor before you switch, and keep using it until a replacement is tested.

If you feel very sleepy while driving, stop driving and get help soon. For the causes of sleep apnea, read sleep apnea risk factors.

FAQs About CPAP Alternatives

Is A Mouth Guard As Good As CPAP?

Not in the AASM review. CPAP lowered breathing events by 6.24 an hour more than an oral appliance. A guideline still suggests an appliance for people who cannot tolerate CPAP.

Can Sleeping On My Side Replace CPAP?

NHLBI says side sleeping can help keep your airway open. The sources here do not say it can replace CPAP, so ask your doctor and have the result tested.

Do Mouth Exercises Cure Sleep Apnea?

No source here says so. In a meta-analysis, exercises lowered AHI by a mean of 8.85 events an hour, but the trials were few and results varied. They may help, alongside medical care.

Is Nerve Stimulation A Surgery?

Yes. NHLBI lists it under surgical procedures. A device is implanted under the skin of the chest and connected to the nerve under your tongue.

Which Alternative Is Best For Mild Sleep Apnea?

The sources we used do not name one. NHLBI says lifestyle changes can be very effective, and your provider can match options to your test results and your symptoms.

Can I Treat Sleep Apnea With Lifestyle Changes Alone?

NHLBI says lifestyle changes can be very effective, but it also notes PAP machines often work best when paired with them. Only a follow-up sleep test shows whether they are enough for you.

Your Next Step

Compare your sleep study AHI before and after treatment to talk about results with your doctor.

Use the AHI Calculator

Sources