Sleep Training Methods: What The Research Shows

Quick Answer: Behavioral sleep training works for many babies, and the trials we read found no lasting harm to stress, attachment or behavior. A review of 52 studies found over 80 percent of treated children improved, and a five-year follow-up found no differences from untreated families. The evidence is strongest for extinction, graduated extinction and bedtime fading. Chair and no-cry methods lack trials. Safe sleep rules still apply.

Check your baby’s rhythm with our baby sleep calculator.

What Is Sleep Training?

Sleep training means teaching a baby to fall asleep and settle back to sleep with less help from a parent. The methods differ in how long you wait before responding and how much you stay in the room. Parents choose among them based on their baby, their own comfort and their values.

No method is right for every family, and not training is also a valid choice. This guide covers what trials found, where evidence is thin and what safety rules stay the same.

What the Evidence Covers for Sleep Training Two columns. Tested in studies: unmodified extinction, graduated extinction, bedtime fading and scheduled awakenings. No trial found in our reading: chair method and no-cry methods. How Well Are Methods Studied? Backed by studiesUnmodified extinctionGraduated extinctionBedtime fading No trial foundChair methodNo-cry methodsA minimum age Based on the studies cited below.

Does Sleep Training Work?

Overall, yes. A review for the American Academy of Sleep Medicine covered 52 treatment studies. Across them, 94 percent reported that behavioral interventions worked, and over 80 percent of treated children improved in a clinically meaningful way that lasted 3 to 6 months. Controlled studies gave the strongest support to unmodified extinction and to preventive parent education, with support for graduated extinction, bedtime fading and scheduled awakenings (Mindell and colleagues, 2006).

The review was of studies in infants and young children, and many were small. It shows that these methods usually help, not that every baby will respond.

Method What you do Evidence we found
Unmodified extinction Put baby down awake and do not respond until morning Strong support in controlled studies (2006 review)
Graduated extinction Check at set, lengthening intervals Supported; tested in a 2016 trial
Bedtime fading Move bedtime closer to when baby falls asleep Supported; tested in a 2016 trial
Chair method Sit by the crib and move the chair away over days No trial found
No-cry methods Gentle soothing and slow changes No trial found

What Is Preventive Parent Education?

It means teaching parents about infant sleep before problems start, for example what normal sleep looks like, how to put a baby down drowsy and how to set a steady routine. The 2006 review found strong support from controlled studies for this approach.

It is the gentlest place to begin. Many families find that knowing what to expect, and keeping bedtime predictable, solves part of the problem without any crying plan at all. We did not find a trial that measures how much it helps for each routine step, so treat the specifics as common practice.

Is Sleep Training Safe For Babies?

The trials we read found no sign of lasting harm. A five-year follow-up of 326 children whose parents had reported sleep problems at 7 months compared families who got behavioral advice with those who did not. At age 6, 225 families took part. There were no differences in emotional or conduct problems, sleep problems (9 percent vs 7 percent), chronic stress (29 percent vs 22 percent), closeness with parents or attachment. The authors called the effects “no marked long-lasting” in either direction (Price and colleagues, 2012).

A small randomized trial also looked at stress hormones and attachment. It followed 43 infants aged 6 to 16 months who were taught graduated extinction, bedtime fading, or sleep education only. Both methods improved sleep compared with the control group. They caused no adverse stress responses, and 12 months later there were no differences in attachment or in the children’s emotions and behavior (Gradisar and colleagues, 2016).

What Are The Limits Of This Evidence?

Be careful not to stretch it. The 43-infant trial is small. The five-year study followed families who got nurse advice, not one exact method. Parents in these trials chose to take part, and none of the studies can show how a particular baby will feel on a particular night.

The studies do not answer every question parents ask. They do not say that crying is pleasant, and they do not cover babies with medical problems. If your baby has reflux, a breathing problem or feeding trouble, talk to the pediatrician first.

What About Help For Parents?

A Canadian trial of 235 families with babies aged 6 to 8 months tested a two-hour group session plus four support calls over two weeks. At six weeks, 4 percent of parents in the program group rated their baby’s sleep problem as severe, compared with 14 percent in the control group. Parents in the program group also reported less depression and fatigue. But nightly waking measured by wrist monitors did not differ: about 97 percent of babies in both groups still woke at least twice a night (Hall and colleagues, 2015).

That result is a useful reminder. Parents felt better and rated the problem as milder even though babies kept waking. If your baby’s waking is normal for the age, a different goal may fit better than training.

Check baby sleep schedule by age for typical ranges.

Then read when babies sleep through the night to set realistic hopes for your baby’s age.

When Should You Start?

We found no guideline that sets a minimum age. The trials above enrolled babies from about 6 months to 16 months, with the nurse program in the five-year study starting at 8 to 10 months. Many parents ask about 4 months. Our guide to the 4-month sleep regression explains why sleep changes then.

Other ages bring their own changes. The baby sleep regressions guide covers them, so you can tell a passing phase from a habit.

Ask your pediatrician before starting, especially for a baby younger than 6 months. Feeding needs and safety needs come first at that age.

Which Safe Sleep Rules Still Apply?

All of them. The American Academy of Pediatrics says babies should sleep alone in a crib or bassinet, on their back, without soft toys, pillows, blankets or other bedding. The surface should be firm, flat and not inclined. It recommends parents share a room with the baby but not a bed, preferably for at least the first six months, and says it cannot support bed-sharing under any circumstances. These recommendations apply to children up to 1 year old (American Academy of Pediatrics).

Sleep training never changes those rules. Read our guide to safe sleep for babies before changing a routine.

How Do You Choose A Method?

These are practical suggestions, not results of the studies:

  • Pick a method you can follow calmly for at least a week or two.
  • Agree on the plan with every adult who helps at night.
  • Start with a steady bedtime routine and an earlier bedtime if your baby is overtired.
  • Skip training during illness, teething pain or big changes such as a move.
  • Stop and call the doctor if your baby seems ill or in pain.

When To See A Doctor

Talk to your pediatrician if your baby snores loudly, pauses in breathing, has trouble feeding, is not gaining weight, seems in pain, or if you feel overwhelmed, hopeless or unable to cope. Postpartum depression is common and treatable.

If your baby is hard to wake, has trouble breathing, or turns blue or gray, call 911. If you have thoughts of harming yourself or your baby, call or text 988 in the US.

FAQs About Sleep Training Methods

What Is The Best Sleep Training Method?

No trial we found shows one method is best. Extinction, graduated extinction and bedtime fading all have supporting evidence, so choose what you can do consistently.

Is Cry It Out Safe?

A five-year follow-up and a small randomized trial found no lasting harm to emotions, behavior, stress or attachment from behavioral methods.

How Long Does Sleep Training Take?

The trials we read did not give one number, so expect it to vary. A review found improvements were kept for 3 to 6 months.

What Age Is Right For Sleep Training?

We found no guideline that sets a minimum age. Trials enrolled babies about 6 months and older, so ask your pediatrician about a younger baby.

Does The Chair Method Work?

We found no trial of the chair method, so we cannot say how well it works.

Can You Sleep Train And Still Follow Safe Sleep Rules?

Yes. Back sleeping, a bare crib or bassinet and room sharing without bed sharing stay the same.

Do Babies Still Wake At Night After Training?

Often yes. In a Canadian trial, about 97 percent of babies in both groups still woke at least twice a night, though parents rated the problem as milder.

Your Next Step

Check naps and night sleep against typical ranges for your baby’s age.

Plan Your Baby’s Day

Sources