Quick Answer: Trackers are good at telling when you are asleep and weak at telling when you are awake. In a lab comparison of seven devices, they caught sleep at least 93 percent of the time but identified wake only 18 to 54 percent of the time. Stage scores, like deep sleep and REM, were inconsistent. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine says they cannot be used to diagnose sleep disorders.
Cross-check your tracker with our sleep score calculator.
How Are Sleep Trackers Tested?
Researchers compare a tracker with polysomnography, the lab recording of brain waves, breathing and movement that serves as the standard. They compare totals, such as hours asleep, and they also compare each 30-second epoch of the night. Epoch checks show whether a device calls the same moments sleep or wake as the lab does.
Most studies use healthy people in a lab, for one to three nights. That limits what they can say about real life. For a look at one popular device, read our guide on whether an Apple Watch can track sleep.
How Well Do Trackers Detect Sleep And Wake?
Very well at sleep and poorly at wake. In a lab study of 34 healthy young adults, researchers tested four wearables and three non-wearable devices over three nights, including a night of disrupted sleep. Most devices did as well as or better than standard actigraphy on sleep and wake measures, and the two Garmin models did worse. Sensitivity to sleep was 0.93 or higher, while specificity for wake was low to medium, from 0.18 to 0.54 (Chinoy and colleagues, 2021).
In plain terms, devices rarely miss sleep, but they often call restless or lying-awake time sleep. Performance was worse on nights with poorer or disrupted sleep, which are the nights people care about most.
| Measure | Lab study of 7 devices |
|---|---|
| Catching sleep (sensitivity) | 0.93 or more |
| Catching wake (specificity) | 0.18 to 0.54 |
| Sleep stages | Mixed, inconsistent |
| Poor or disrupted nights | Worse performance |
Do Fitbits Over- Or Underestimate Sleep?
Models without stage tracking tended to overestimate sleep. A meta-analysis screened 3,085 candidate articles, included 22 in the review and 8 in the pooled analysis. Compared with the lab, non-staging Fitbit models overestimated total sleep time by about 7 to 67 minutes (effect size -0.51) and sleep efficiency by roughly 2 to 15 percent (-0.74). They underestimated time awake after falling asleep by about 6 to 44 minutes (0.60) (Haghayegh and colleagues, 2019).
There was no significant difference in time to fall asleep. Epoch accuracy ran from 0.81 to 0.91, and specificity was as low as 0.10. These are standardized effect sizes pooled across models, so your own device may differ. If you want to check the arithmetic on efficiency, read our guide on how to calculate hours of sleep.
How Accurate Are Sleep Stages?
Less accurate than totals. In a study of the Oura ring in 41 healthy adolescents and young adults, summary measures for time to fall asleep, total sleep time and time awake were not different from the lab. But the ring underestimated deep sleep (N3) by about 20 minutes and overestimated REM by about 17 minutes. Epoch-by-epoch, it detected sleep with 96 percent sensitivity, but agreement was 65 percent for light sleep, 51 percent for deep sleep and 61 percent for REM, and its specificity for wake was 48 percent (de Zambotti and colleagues, 2019).
Total sleep time and time awake were within 30 minutes of the lab for about 87.8 and 85.4 percent of people. The ring also placed 90.9, 81.3 and 92.9 percent of people into the right range for under 6 hours, 6 to 7 hours and over 7 hours. Totals are therefore more trustworthy than stages. See our guide on how much deep sleep you need before worrying about a low deep sleep number.
How Was The Oura Ring Study Done?
Each person wore the ring during one overnight stay in a sleep lab, and the ring’s data were compared with polysomnography using Bland-Altman plots, which show the size of the gaps, and epoch-by-epoch analysis. The researchers set a goal in advance: a difference of 30 minutes or less counted as clinically satisfactory.
Gaps in time awake were larger in people who had more time awake in the lab recording. The ring’s deep sleep readings also fell with age, as did the lab’s own deep sleep. The authors called the first results promising but said more development and validation are needed. The participants were healthy teenagers and young adults tested on a single night, so the results may not hold for older people or for people with sleep disorders.
What Do Sleep Doctors Say About Trackers?
The American Academy of Sleep Medicine has issued a position statement on consumer sleep technology. It notes that these devices lack validation against polysomnography and FDA clearance, so they cannot be used to diagnose or treat sleep disorders at this time. It adds that they may still help a conversation between patient and clinician, and calls for future validation, access to raw data and algorithms, and FDA oversight (Khosla and colleagues, 2018).
So treat your tracker as a diary, not a diagnosis. If you suspect a problem such as sleep apnea, a doctor can order a proper test. Our guide on what happens during a sleep study explains what that involves.
Can Trackers Make Sleep Worse?
For some people, yes. Clinicians describe orthosomnia, a growing pattern of patients who seek treatment for self-diagnosed sleep problems based on tracker data, such as light or restless sleep. Their inferred link between tracker data and daytime fatigue can turn into a perfectionistic quest for ideal sleep. To these patients, tracker data often feels more consistent with their experience than validated techniques do (Baron and colleagues, 2017).
The authors suggested that clinicians balance explaining how valid these devices are with respect for patients’ enthusiasm, and that trackers could be built into cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia. The paper is a clinical viewpoint, not a trial.
How Should You Use A Tracker?
These are practical suggestions, not findings from the studies above:
- Look at weekly trends in total sleep, not single nights.
- Treat deep sleep and REM numbers as rough.
- Trust how you feel in the day over a score.
- Do not diagnose yourself from the data. Share it with a doctor if you are worried.
- Check who funded any validation study you read.
If tracker scores are making you anxious about sleep, read our guide on sleep tracking and insomnia.
How Strong Is The Evidence?
Moderate for totals, weak for stages. The lab studies are small, often 34 to 41 people, and use healthy young adults, so they may not match older or sicker users. The Fitbit review covers older models. New devices and software updates arrive faster than studies do.
When To See A Doctor
Talk to a doctor if you snore loudly, stop breathing in your sleep, feel very sleepy in the day, or sleep badly for weeks, whatever your tracker says. A normal score does not rule out a sleep disorder.
If you feel unsafe to drive, do not drive. If you feel hopeless or think about harming yourself, call or text 988 in the US.
FAQs About Whether Sleep Trackers Are Accurate
How Accurate Is A Sleep Tracker For Total Sleep Time?
Reasonably, for many devices. In one lab study, the Oura ring was within 30 minutes of the lab for most people, but Fitbit models without staging tended to overestimate sleep.
Can A Tracker Tell Me When I Am Awake At Night?
Not well. Wake detection (specificity) was only 0.18 to 0.54 across seven devices, and the Oura ring had 48 percent.
Are Deep Sleep And REM Numbers Reliable?
Not very. The Oura ring misjudged deep sleep by about 20 minutes and REM by about 17, and stage agreement was 51 to 65 percent.
Can A Tracker Diagnose Sleep Apnea?
No. The AASM says consumer sleep technology cannot be used for diagnosis or treatment of sleep disorders at this time.
Which Tracker Is Most Accurate?
The studies we read tested a handful of models in small groups. Most devices did as well as or better than actigraphy, and the Garmin models did worse in one study.
Why Does My Tracker Say I Slept Longer Than I Felt?
Fitbit models without staging overestimated total sleep time by about 7 to 67 minutes in a meta-analysis. The studies we read did not test why, so we cannot give a reason.
What Is Orthosomnia?
A clinical term for worry about sleep driven by tracker data, which can lead people to chase ideal scores.
Your Next Step
Turn your time in bed and time asleep into one percentage.
Sources
- Performance of seven consumer sleep-tracking devices compared with polysomnography (Sleep, 2021)
- Accuracy of wristband Fitbit models in assessing sleep: systematic review and meta-analysis (J Med Internet Res, 2019)
- The sleep of the ring: comparison of the OURA sleep tracker against polysomnography (Behavioral Sleep Medicine, 2019)
- Consumer sleep technology: an American Academy of Sleep Medicine position statement (J Clin Sleep Med, 2018)
- Orthosomnia: are some patients taking the quantified self too far? (J Clin Sleep Med, 2017)